Christian Nationalists and The Extraction Class: A Fragile Alliance Built to Break

The Civil War Brewing Within MAGA: Part 6

Critical Resistance -- Substack

Feb 21, 2025

In previous installments, we dissected the MAGA movement’s key factions—The Christian Nationalists, The Extraction Class, and The Militant Extremists—as well as Donald Trump’s role as the movement’s figurehead. Each faction has its own endgame, but their uneasy alliance has been crucial to their collective rise to power. However, cracks are beginning to form. Among them, the most surprising common ground exists between two seemingly incompatible forces: the religious extremists of The Christian Nationalists and the corporate overlords of The Extraction Class. Their visions for America’s future are fundamentally at odds, yet their shared goals in dismantling democracy have kept them aligned—for now.

The Unholy Alliance: Short-Term Goals, Long-Term Conflicts

At first glance, a faction of religious zealots yearning for a theocratic state and a cadre of tech billionaires envisioning an AI-driven corporate autocracy seem like polar opposites. Yet, their current alliance is forged by overlapping short-term goals: dismantling democratic institutions, minimizing government oversight, and consolidating power into the hands of a select few.

Despite these shared objectives, their fundamental ideologies are irreconcilable. The Christian Nationalists believe in divinely ordained authority, biblical law, and a strict moral hierarchy. The Extraction Class believes in technocratic rule, algorithmic governance, and a world shaped by capital and efficiency. Their partnership is a temporary convenience, not a lasting vision.

Their biggest challenge is not seizing power—it’s what happens afterward. The Christian Nationalists want a religious state, while The Extraction Class wants an economic empire. These goals are incompatible, and the moment one faction moves to secure control, the other will see it as a threat.

(more)

READ MORE: Critical Resistance

Image: Critical Resistance